Guidelines for Audits of the Financial Statements of Charter Schools
The New York charter schools act of nineteen hundred ninety-eight requires that a charter school “shall be subject to the financial audits, the audit procedures, and the audit requirements set forth in the charter. Such procedures and standards shall be applied consistent with generally accepted accounting and audit standards. Independent fiscal audits shall be required at least once annually.”
These guidelines are provided to assist charter schools in New York State and their auditors through the annual audit process. The guidelines are also intended to provide some uniformity in the reporting by charter schools and to assist the Board of Regents in meeting its responsibilities for ensuring accountability over public funds and for reporting annually to the Governor and Legislature on the status of charter schools.
Each audit should meet the following minimum standards:
- An independent and licensed Certified Public Accountant or Public Accountant should perform the audit.
- The audits should be conducted in accordance with generally accepted auditing standards and Government Auditing Standards, issued by the Comptroller General of the United States.
- If the charter school spends $500,000 or more in federal awards during the fiscal year, an independent audit as prescribed in the federal Office of Management and Budget Circular A-133 must also be completed and filed with the federal government and the State Education Department.
- Regents authorized schools and any school that received Federal Charter School Program (CSP) funds must follow guidance in the Charter School Audit Guide which is located at:
- The sample format for the financial statements is provided in accordance with Section 2851 of the Education Law.
- The financial statements should be prepared on the accrual basis of accounting in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles for not-for-profit organizations.
- All statements required by Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) Statement No. 117, Financial Statements of Not-for-Profit Organizations, should be presented including a Statement of Financial Position, Statement of Activities and Statement of Cash Flows. Required note disclosures and others that are deemed appropriate should be included.
- A supplemental schedule of functional expenses, in a format consistent with the attached, should be included and subject to the auditing procedures applied in the audit of the general purpose financial statements. Such supplemental schedule is not a required part of the general purpose financial statements and should be included for the purposes of additional analysis.
- When applicable, the auditor should prepare and submit a management letter. A copy of the management letter should be submitted with the financial statements along with the school’s corrective action plan to address any weaknesses identified in the report or the management letter.
- Required submissions: the independent auditor’s report on the financial statements, report on compliance and report on internal control over financial reporting and management letter
- If applicable, the following must also be submitted:
- the federal Single Audit
- Charter School Program Agreed Upon Procedure Report
2012 - 2013 Submission of Audits of Financial Statements:
ALL New York State Charter Schools must submit Audits of Financial Statements in electronic form within 120 days of the end of the charter school fiscal year. The process and format to submit the audited financial statements is described in the 2012-13 Annual Report Guidelines, which is located at:
- Annual Report Guidelines - detailed information regarding key focus areas and authorizer requirements
New York Charter schools will meet the Annual Report tasks within the SED’s Charter School Office online portal found at: https://nysed-cso-reports.myreviewroom.com. Within the online portal is additional resources for schools.
- Annual Report Instructions - for logging into and using the online portal
- Template for Unaudited Financial Statements (Board of Regents-authorized charter schools only)
SAMPLE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
Sample financial statements are provided for illustrative purposes. Charter schools and their auditors should consult applicable standards when determining the specific requirements that apply to their schools. The auditor should not consider these examples to be all-inclusive or a substitute for professional judgment.
The following sample financial statements can be accesed using the links:
- For Schedule of Functional Expenses, see sample schedule on page 28 of Charter School Audit Guide, located at: Audit Guide
Explanations are provided below for certain key terms included in the sample financial statements:
Public School District:
Revenue - Resident Student Enrollment - Revenue from public school districts based on resident students attending the charter school and each district’s adjusted expense per student or the agreed upon amount per student.
Revenue - Students with Disabilities - Revenue from public school districts for aid attributable to special education services or programs provided by the charter school to a student with a disability enrolled in the charter school.
Other Revenue from Public School Districts - Revenues from public school districts other than those defined above.
State Grants: Report state funded grants or other apportionments received directly from the State of New York.
Federal Grants: Report federal funded grants or other apportionments received directly from the federal government or through the State of New York.
Private Grants: Report privately funded grants or other apportionments received.
Program Service Expenses:
Regular Education- Report instructional activities involving the teaching of students, instructional supervision, developing and utilizing learning materials and related services in the classroom or learning environment.
Special Education- Report instructional activities involving the teaching of students with Individualized Education Programs, or those receiving special education services, instructional supervision, developing and utilizing learning materials and related services in the classroom or learning environment.
Other Program- Services other than instructional provided to students, i.e., community services, health services, food services, athletic services, music and theatre arts, and other student activities.
Supporting Service Expenses:
Management and General- Activities related to the overall management and direction of the school that are not identifiable with a particular program or fundraising activity. Management and general expenses typically include the organization oversight, board expenses, business management, record keeping, budgeting, financing and other administrative activities.
Fundraising- Activities related to publicizing and conducting fund-raising campaigns, maintaining donor mailing lists, conducting special fund-raising events, activities involved in the solicitation of contributions from individuals, foundations, government agencies, etc.
Schedule of Functional Expenses:
The schedule of functional expenses must present, in reasonable detail, the nature of the expenses incurred in each category of program and supporting services reported in the activity statement. The sample schedule shows the typical level of detail expected. Charter schools are encouraged to add additional categories if it will enhance the reader’s understanding of the schedule. Likewise, classifications not used, or not material to the school’s presentation, may be eliminated.
If not otherwise presented, charter schools employing management companies should obtain and provide in note disclosure a breakdown of contracted services fees in a similar format to the schedule of functional expenses to facilitate comparisons among districts.
Note on Allocation of Expenses: Charter schools must use allocation methods that are fair and reasonable. Such allocation methods, as well as the statistical basis used to calculate allocation percentages, should be documented and retained for review upon audit. Salaries of employees who perform tasks for more than one program must be allocated among all programs for which they work. The cost of supplies that are purchased for distribution among multiple programs must be allocated among these programs if direct charges are not possible. Allocation percentages should be reviewed, at a minimum, on an annual basis and adjusted as necessary.